Six cars for college

steve

With "LOD" Since 1997
And none are domestic.

http://money.cnn.com/2003/07/14/pf/autos/college_cars/index.htm

Six cars for college
If you're considering supplying wheels for your college-bound kids, here are some suggestions.
August 7, 2003: 10:20 AM EDT
By Lawrence Ulrich, MONEY Magazine

NEW YORK (CNN/Money) - So, your child is college-bound but car-less. And in a fit of generosity, you're inclined to spring for a set of student wheels.

After wiping away a tear -- for the impending departure of teen-ager and money alike -- you're ready to deal. As with any back-to-school shopping, choosing a great collegiate car will require calm negotiating. A compromise between the rad ride every youngster wants and what you -- as the older, wiser parent -- know they need. (If that fails, remind your little frosh who's cutting the check.)

We don't need to remind mom and dad that even a single year of college costs as much as a new car. So we urge most parents to first consider a used model. Even a 6- or 8-year-old vehicle shouldn't induce guilt or worry, as long as mileage is reasonable and it's been well-maintained. A fraction of the money you'll save can go toward replacing worn items like brakes and tires, ensuring trusty operation. (Do make sure any used model is equipped with anti-lock brakes, a critical safety factor for young and relatively inexperienced drivers.)

Whether it's a new or used car, also consider making this a helpful introduction to the real world of monthly payments. For a responsible young adult, the privilege of driving a nice car or truck might include covering the insurance, or an agreed-upon share of the monthly payments. Or at least gas and maintenance.

Finally, while we're not ignoring style and performance, practicality, economy, affordability and safety take precedence here. With those ground rules set for College Cars 101, here are a few models that earn an A for the fall semester:

No-brainers, new or used
Toyota Corolla: Toyota sees its Matrix, a funky-hatch version of the Corolla, as the model of choice for the college set. But here's where the wise parent comes in: The Corolla sedan may not have the Matrix' hipster name and styling, but it's a notably better car.

Introduced as a 2002 model, the latest-generation Corolla is probably the most faultless small sedan on the planet: roomy, comfortable, quiet, surprisingly powerful, built to quality standards few cars can match. The styling might elicit yawns or even whines from your progeny, but they'll settle down once they see the inferior cars broken down outside the dorm.

If they're helping out with payments, they'll also appreciate the $14,855 base price for the base 2004 Corolla CE. A three-year-old 2000 Corolla CE isn't as sophisticated as the current version, but it runs roughly $8,000-to-$10,000. And the Corolla's exceptional resale value has even '97 models going for $4,000-to-$6,000.

Honda Civic: A hard-earned reputation for quality means you'll pay a stiff premium for Honda vehicles -- new or used. That includes the Civic, a compact sedan, coupe or hatchback that can be whatever your student driver wants it to be: A low-key econobox or a tricked-out, Fast and Furious street rod.

Practical collegians will lean toward the fuel-sipping HX coupe at $14,710 with a continuously variable automatic transmission. The gas-electric hybrid version is even more fuel-efficient, but the price is a disconcerting $20,550. One more downer: Anti-lock brakes are only available on the Civic hybrid, sporty Si hatchback and top-shelf EX models.

The bright side is that Civics are as reliable as final exams and really hold their value: One popular model, the Civic LX sedan, is still worth $9,000-to-$11,500 for year-2000 models, or $5,500-to-$7,500 for a '97 version.

Honda CR-V: Among compact SUVs, both the Jeep Liberty and Nissan Xterra offer more collegian curb appeal, along with more off-road ability. But the Honda rides, handles and stops better than its truckish rivals, is easier on gas, better-built and costs less comparably equipped: Base price for 2003 is $19,610 for front-wheel-drive models with side air bags.

The CR-V's 160-horsepower, 2.4-liter four-cylinder is so deceptively powerful you'll never miss the V-6s offered by competitors. Throw in Honda quality, outstanding safety and a higher projected resale value, and the CR-V wins despite its yawner looks. Year 2000 models are still fetching $12,000-to-$16,500, depending on mileage and equipment.

New cars
Hyundai Elantra and Elantra GT: Industry laughingstock no longer, South Korea's Hyundai has seen sales explode after boosting quality and expanding its power train warranty to a confidence-inspiring 10 years/100,000 miles.

Starting at $12,499, the peppy Elantra sedan and hatchback simply deliver more features for less money than the competition: At $14,149, the GT sedan and hatchback include standard four-wheel disc brakes, side air bags, leather upholstery and steering wheel, CD player, heated power mirrors, alloy wheels, remote keyless entry, intermittent wipers and more. Another $1,033 gets you traction control, ABS and a sunroof. One caveat: Resale value continues to trail the class leaders from Honda and Toyota.

Cars for the Little Prince or Princess
For those with a little more cash to spend and kids they don't mind spoiling, here are a couple of slightly pricier options.

New Car -- Mini Cooper: If tuition hasn't already wiped you out, and your 4.0-average offspring is deserving, nothing will inspire campus envy like the Mini Cooper. Starting at $16,850, BMW's brilliant redesign of the pint-sized British classic is cool, practical, fuel-efficient, easy to park, and a blast to drive and to be seen in.

And this isn't the modern, irresponsible equivalent of buying a Camaro for your teen: Front-wheel-drive, reassuring handling and just 115 horsepower (160 horsepower for the $19,850 Cooper S) ensure drivers won't get in over their head. The back seat is minuscule, but then college students are the least likely to grouse about a free ride. And despite David size in a world of SUV Goliaths, the Mini delivers top marks in crash testing, with a comprehensive roster of active and passive safety features including eight air bags and available stability control.

Used Car -- Volkswagen Jetta: The Jetta costs substantially more than its small-sedan competition, giving us pause in recommending it as a new car. And before you get all huffy, no, the Jetta's overall reliability doesn't equal the best from Japan. (Neither does Mercedes, but you don't see many Benz owners trading for a Camry.) The point is that young people are smart, and VWs like the Jetta have earned their enthusiastic loyalty for very good reasons.

The Jetta's sophisticated German character shines through in styling, performance and interior craftsmanship, making this a solid used-car buy. A three-year-old 2000 Jetta GL can be had for less than $12,000. That year's Jetta GLS 1.8T, equipped with the terrific turbocharged four-cylinder also found in the Passat sedan and Audi's TT and A4 models, is fetching $12,500-to-$15,000, depending on mileage and options.

Lawrence Ulrich writes about cars for Money Magazine. You can contact him at autos@money.com.
 
RE: Six cars for college

The guy is so full of manure that he is attracting flys over the 'net! I wrote him a note he'll not forget! He's the kind to tie an American flag on his Kia and not see anything wrong with it, nor the hypocrocy in it! What a dummy! $15,000 a semester for college, and he wants me to buy a 7-8 year old Jap-Crap Tin Box with unknown care & no warrantee & little to no safety features and no roadside assist to send "Junior" off in to drive 70MPH on the highways at night in the dark! Geeez! Then he wants the kid to work and go to college full time and earn "A"s while working to pay his own insurance ($3,500 @ yr) on the POS.
Just the kinda guy that probably goes to Atlantic City or Vegas & drops $7,000 at the craps table, too I'll bet!
Some parents really amaze me, and then they are bewildered at the way their kids turn out.
Look in the freakin' mirror & you'll see WHY they turned out that way, Mr. Ulrich! Better they wear A&P sneakers at $25.00 a pair and have a safe car, than Nike $200.00 sneakers & a Hyundai Tin Box.
 
RE: Six cars for college

This guy does understand that a bigger car is a safer car. US crash tests are biased to help the sale of smaller cars to save gas. Statistics show that larger cars are safer in the real world. See http://www.highwaysafety.org/vehicle_ratings/ictl/ictl_4dr.htm and http://www.highwaysafety.org/vehicle_ratings/ictl/ictl_2dr.htm .

I would not buy any of those small deathtraps he listed for my child. And I would not buy an import which would help pay for college tuitions for foreigners instead of Americans.

If he wanted to buy the safest most reliable car for his child a used Lincoln Town Car or Ford Crown Victoria would be a better choice. They are safer and have durability and relability that Hondas and Toyotas could only dream of. Reaching 400,000 miles is routine for Town Cars in fleet service. If a Honda or Toyota reachs that mileage, it is used in a national ad campaign.
 
RE: Six cars for college

About the Mini Cooper: And this isn't the modern, irresponsible equivalent of buying a Camaro for your teen: Front-wheel-drive, reassuring handling and just 115 horsepower (160 horsepower for the $19,850 Cooper S) ensure drivers won't get in over their head.

Most of the Camaro’s of the late seventies and early eighties, when they were at the peak of their popularity with young people, had lower horsepower ratings than the Mini Cooper that he raves about. See http://www.nastyz28.com/camaro/camaro80.html . Only two of the V-8's in 1980 in the Camaro had horsepower over 155. The V-6 in that year had at most 115 horsepower. These cars had a weight and transmission disadvantage compared to the new Mini Cooper. Those Camaro’s cannot get the acceleration and top speed that these new Mini Coopers can reach.

The author of that article on cars for college kids should do some extensive reading on cars and then take a course in logic before he writes any more articles.


Alexander
President
Lincolns of Distinction
 
RE: Six cars for college

Man has no more car-knowledge than I have knitting knowledge! He's to be ignored.
 
RE: Six cars for college

Sandy,

Can you please write an article on knitting for the next LOD newsletter. I am sure it would be better than that guy's article on cars.

Alexander
President
Lincolns of Distinction
 
RE: Six cars for college

when you are first learning to dirve in my family, you have to drive the '85 Chevy 3/4 ton Full-Size pickup for a year before you are allowed to drive any of the other cars, let alone get your own. When I was still 16 I was at a stop light and got rearended at 30 mph by a hyundai(sp?). The beats truck lurched forward about a foot and stopped. I got out to find this crumpled up POS half under my truck. Whne I told the cops that I was alright, I started the truck back up and they wanted to see if I could move. I was dragging the little ##### box for a little ways before it finnally broke loose and the radiator was still attached to the pintle hitch. Anf there was no damage to the custom 3/8" steel bubmber on the back of the truck, same some minor scratches, but nothing a few swipes with some black spray paint couldnt take care of.

Moral of the story: if you drive a little sh!tty foreign car, watch out for large stoped american pick-ups. They kick your ass.
 
RE: Six cars for college

Lawrence Ulrich is featured weekly in the Detroit Free Press in Thursdays "Motor City" section. Quite honestly, I do not agree with most of the stuff he writes about. I miss Tony Swan.
 
RE: Six cars for college

That Guy is a moron.....

'98 Pristine Pearlescent LSC
'93 V-10 Twin Turbo Money Pit (The MonsterMark)
'93 Collecting Dust
Bryan
 
RE: Six cars for college

Six Cars for College:-

6. AMC Gremlin Levis

5. Mercury Bobcat

4. Original Subaru 360

3. Chevrolet Vega

2. Fiat 164

1. Renault Dauphane

Bonus Car for Honor Students:-

Cadillac Cimmaron d' Oro
 
RE: Six cars for college

My college car was a '95 Subaru Impreza LX (2.2L AWD). Held up great, but that thing was not meant for 70+mph interstate cruising (1.5 hours of 3000+ RPMs; I'm using about as much gas now as I was then even though the Mark is heavier with a bigger engine :D ).

And I don't see what sort of college-aged male would want to drive around a Mini Cooper. I guess you could use it to attract females, but only because they'll assume you're gay.
 
RE: Six cars for college

Let's see...

College cars...

Sophmore & Junior year -- '66 Chevy Impala - standard shift - no power anything - 2 gallons of bondo and a cardboard box full of used parts - and a few cans of oil.

Senior Year -- '66 Mustang - Red with about a quart of bondo in it - side pipes that leaked constantly - but the car never made me walk. Sold it the summer I graduated and bought a '72 Triumph Spitfire - at the end of the summer traded it for my brother's 74 Vega Wagon (a plastic woodie) - so I could actually get to my first "big boy" job 500 miles from Detroit.
 
RE: Six cars for college

Freshman year -- '92 Ford Explorer Eddie Bauer 4x4

Sophmore year -- bought the '96 Mark :)
 
Back
Top