I'm headed out of town right after work today, but when I get back on Sunday I will take some pics of the handles and do some checking to see if they are the same from 94 to 98. Otherwise, I do have both handles and I know that they both work, but I honestly haven't paid much attention to how "tight" they feel. I'll check them out and get with you.
the whole handle is pot metal, the only thing plastic on it is the ring around it between the handle and the door, and the plastic linkage pins that the linkage rods go through, otherwise the entire thing is metal, not plastic, and changing the cylinder doesnt cost anything, you take it out of the broken handle and pop it into the new handle!