RE: electric water pump questions
Here's my take, yeah there's no 'free' lunch but you don't need to be a glutton either!
The belt driven water pump is wasting HP at higher RPM's beyond what the cooling system requires. The electric pump is a constant speed and therefore constant load. The mechanical driven pump requires more HP with more rpms, period. The difference at any rpm is the HP gain at that rpm.
I plan on installing one this winter or in the spring so perhaps I'll have some personal experience to pass along at a later date. In preparation for it though I have a new hi-performance alternator and a new dry-cell Odyessey battery.
IMHO if you have a problem with the electric pump it will be the charging system. My rebuilt alternator was only supplying 20 amps at idle. The new 160 amp alternator from PA-Performance is advertised to be 80 amps at idle. I measured 50+ amps output at idle with everything on the Mark VIII(including the cooling fan on max). So I still have some overhead available for the additional load of the electric water pump. I would not recommend you get the electric pump until you upgrade the charging system. I guarantee if you only have 20-30 amps available at idle, you will be discharging the battery at idle. If you have a yellow top Optima, it will help, but it too will be depleted sooner than you think.