OK, I'll agree with Leo's assessment. Yes, the Market Cross Pub had a great selection of beers, and IIRC the food (mine at least) was really good. However, it was a small room comparatively. I forgot about the separate check thing.
The Sunnyside had room, but the food wasn't good (I ordered lobster, and it was WAY overcooked), but I could get something else next year, lol. They closed really early too it seemed.
I didn't realize Gingerbread didn't have private rooms, so that'd be out.
Why the hell you would order lobster in Pennsatucky, next time try the possum road kill.